why do Japanese?

Japanese Reenactment Society forum. run by Tanaka.
http://groups.msn.com/WW2J-R-A/

Moderator: Tanaka

User avatar
Hirate Sakimori
Posts: 13
Joined: Tue Dec 30, 2014 4:04 pm
Location: Wild West Midlands

Re: why do Japanese?

Post by Hirate Sakimori »

Just thought of another important reason to do Japanese... "Our War" was much much longer... 8 years of fighting... and for some brave and perhaps unlucky souls the war went on even longer then that.... :o

Japan's world war 2 technically went off with a blast in 1937 when they fought against the Chinise...
The Chinese were very brave and even had extensive help from Germany... great irony yes but war is never simple...

At epic battles like Shanghai it is well documented how it was like the "Stalingrad of the East" when generalissimo Chang KaiShek tried to open a Northern front against the Japanese Imperial Forces in Manchukou (Manchuria)

This battle was famous because Chang threw his best German trained and equipped divisions like the legendary 88th which had soldiers dressed and kitted like Wermacht fighting IJA Marines and Infantry battalions in the Streets of Shanghai itself.

Also the size of the conquests of Japanese forces in World war 2 was huge... in a few Months IJA and IJN had snatched 1 fifth of the Worlds surface from the Allied forces of Britian, Dutch, American and Australians... while also thrashing the French in Indo China as well...

Many people have negative attitude towards Japanese forces, not surprisingly because of terrible brutality by some members of IJA but we must remember most IJA officers hated those seemingly "Fascist" characters as well... while vast majority simply followed orders... anyway aside from politics and the horror of post combat prison/death camps.

Japanese forces are also special because of some unique characteristics to their forces. Chronic lack of heavy firepower, air support in later years and also lack of sufficient heavy artillery and armour meant the IJA had to develop specialised jungle warfare tactics, aggressive patrolling and counter patrolling, booby traps, ambushes and other grisly aspects of guerrilla warfare.

Plus the asymmetric nature of Japanese fighting tactics is a harsh thing for many to learn but the tactical rewards are very good and one can easily transfer such skills. I think there is a huge potential in this aspect.
User avatar
Ted
Posts: 642
Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 2:19 am
Location: Buckinghamshire

Re: why do Japanese?

Post by Ted »

while also thrashing the French in Indo China as well...

Nope, The French had already surrenderd to Germany & Japan took advantage to take over the Indochine provinces. They just walked in un opposed.
User avatar
Hirate Sakimori
Posts: 13
Joined: Tue Dec 30, 2014 4:04 pm
Location: Wild West Midlands

Re: why do Japanese?

Post by Hirate Sakimori »

Definitely not walked in unnaposed... Yes the French Government and France had surrendered to Germany... but the Colony of Indo China put up a fight... they first thoroughly whipped the Thai's who took advantage of the European situation... and then it was the Thai's who requested Japans help... in return for letting Japan use Thailand as a pit stop for their invasion of Malaya... :) The French colonies fought well despite the Government leaving them to it... Also the Dutch gave a good account of themselves too. France beat Thailand but couldn't hope to stop the Japanese after the ABDACOM fiasco
Post Reply

Return to “Japanese Discussion”